Best Grimrock full mods so far?

[coreystinson]

I'm looking for some thoughts, comments, and reviews on existing full-game mods for Grimrock 1 - essentially, mods that are all-new dungeons and complete games. Heavy use of new assets (walls, monsters, etc.) is appreciated, as well is a well-thought out story. I've played through a few already and so far I've found these three to be brilliant:

- The Sunset Gate
- Mines of Malan Vael
- One Room Round Robin 2

Others, such as The Reeking Depths, show a solid understanding of the dungeon editor and scripting but don't really present anything all that new or interesting.

Anyone have any thoughts or can you point me to a list of reviews that might already exist?

[Dr.Disaster]

I'm looking for some thoughts, comments, and reviews on existing full-game mods for Grimrock 1 - essentially, mods that are all-new dungeons and complete games. Heavy use of new assets (walls, monsters, etc.) is appreciated, as well is a well-thought out story. I've played through a few already and so far I've found these three to be brilliant:

- The Sunset Gate
- Mines of Malan Vael
- One Room Round Robin 2

Others, such as The Reeking Depths, show a solid understanding of the dungeon editor and scripting but don't really present anything all that new or interesting.

Anyone have any thoughts or can you point me to a list of reviews that might already exist?

Follow the links inside Komag's "Finished Dungeons" thread at the top of the mod forum. You'll find both info and reviews there.

[LocalFire]

Reviews: viewtopic.php?f=11&t=6501

[andyroosta]

Excellent reviews LocalFire..very helpful.